Concert Review – Handel’s Messiah – Camerata Tinta Barocca, Cape Consort

St Andrew’s Presbyterian Church, Wednesday 10 December 2014

Reviewed by Andy Wilding


2014 is a benchmark for the perseverance and success of classical music in Cape Town: the Cape Town Philharmonic Orchestra turned 100, and Camerata Tinta Barocca turned 10. This collaboration for Handel’s Messiah with the Cape Consort, a well established Cape Town based ensemble of singers and period instruments, was an uplifting example of the mutual benefit and synergy that occurs when independent groups combine their resources and produce a holistic result – “the whole is greater than the sum of its parts”.

Moments into the friendly warm sound of period strings and basso continuo filling the space I felt surrounded by wigs and baroquely ornamented dark wood furnishings. The ensemble seemed to have an intuition for singing and playing together like a family, and although directed from the harpsichord (Erik Dippennar) they have the eye contact and engagement with each other that happens when musicians take full responsibility for their own sound.

The whole sound was surprisingly full with only 11 singers in total, capturing the feeling of a chorus of angels. I enjoyed the humorously fitting sanctimonious tone in “And he shall purify the sons Levi…” – a hint of tongue-in-cheek “told you so, you were naughty” feeling in the interpretation.

“For unto us a child is born” was brisk and exciting, and the chorus did well keeping up with semiquavers at this refreshing pace. It was a beautiful description of the architecture of Heaven according to Handel. And something happens when a great work like this is performed well: one can “see” what the composer “saw”. It is for me the mark of a good performance. (I loved the quick tuning break after all that excitement, so baroque!)

Handel's Messiah - Camerata Tinta Barocca, Cape Consort

Our soloists for the evening were, in keeping with the integrity of the period, also the chorus. Alto Monika Voysey has a commanding presence, good drama, and lovely tone. Sopranos Lente Louw, Elsabe Richter, and Antoinette Blyth were stirring, exquisitely accompanied by the piccolo trumpets of Mike Blake and Brendan Kierman. I did rejoice greatly! (The Botticellian images were most entertaining) There were times when I looked for second singer, but the counterpoint I was hearing was the lyrical voice of Emile de Roubaix’s viola.

The “Hallelujah” was unique. 25 People reaching ever higher into Heaven with voices and trumpets and drums, this incredible heart expanding harmony that heralded the great romantic requiems, this amazing power, and what a pleasure to hear the full simple glory of this work performed so close to the original orchestration, the way Handel heard it. CTB and the Cape Consort recreated that mystical sound that later became the subject of endless popularity and speculation. And it is stunning! If the whole world could hear the fugal amen chorus that we heard last night, it may well be enough to create peace on Earth – Heavens shining gates opening right here and letting us in.

Handel's Messiah - Camerata Tinta Barocca, Cape Consort

With Quentin Crida and Erik Dippenaar

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s